We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best
products—learn more about
our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.
A new mattress is an investment in your health, but you don’t need to break the bank to get quality sleep. When it comes to spending your own hard-earned cash, you want to make sure you’re getting the best mattress for the money. Online you’ll find dozens of affordable beds that provide the support and comfort you need to rest easy night after night.
In search of high-quality and budget-friendly options, the experts at Mattress Advisor tested and reviewed hundreds of beds under $1,700 to determine which ones are actually worth buying. They assigned a score to each mattress using a 14-point methodology that includes categories such as durability, spine alignment, and cooling. Here are their top 10 picks.
Tips for Finding the Best Mattress for Your Money
Buy Online
When you purchase a mattress in-store, you tend to pay for more than just the bed itself. A portion of the price often goes towards extraneous things like marketing and overhead. On the flip side, bed-in-a-box companies sell directly to customers, cutting out the middleman to keep more money in your pocket.
Shop Seasonal Sales
Mattress companies are known to offer serious discounts and product freebies during holidays like President's Day, Memorial Day, Labor Day, Black Friday, and Cyber Monday. The best part is that most of these sales last for a full week or weekend rather than just 24 hours.
Check Trial Periods and Warranties
Both in-store and bed-in-a-box mattresses come with generous warranties, which can save you money if you run into issues with your bed. Mattress companies also offer free sleep trials, allowing you to try out the mattress for a number of nights (typically 100 or more) before committing. If you decide it's not the right fit, you can return it for a full refund.
How Long Does a Mattress Last?
A good mattress can last seven to 10 years if you take care of it. You can extend a bed's lifespan by using a mattress protector, which guards against stains. Durable materials like steel coils and high-density memory foam resist sagging and degradation, helping your mattress keep its shape and withstand the wear and tear of nightly use.
Best Mattress Type for the Money
Innerspring
If your budget is tight, consider an innerspring mattress. It's typically the most inexpensive type of bed, containing coils topped with a thin layer of foam to provide lasting support.
Memory Foam
Memory foam is known for its body-hugging comfort, and while some models cost a pretty penny, you can find others priced at under $1,000. Memory foam mattresses are great at isolating motion, which allows couples or pet owners to remain undisturbed if their companion (human or animal) frequently tosses and turns during the night.
Hybrid
Hybrid beds combine two or more mattress materials (usually foam and coils) for a wider range of sleep benefits, such as balancing the comfort of foam with the spinal support of innerspring coils. This mix often makes hybrids more durable than other types of bed, but it also drives up the price.
Latex
Latex mattresses are more buoyant than memory foam beds, but provide the same level of contouring and pressure relief. They also tend to be the most expensive kind of mattress because they're extremely durable and can last a long time.
The 10 Best Mattresses for the Money
Best Overall: Saatva Classic
A Mattress Advisor tester tells Shape that Brooklyn Bedding’s Signature is one of the highest ranking mattresses for pressure relief (it scored a 9.5 out of 10 in the category) thanks to its premium quilted topper that cushions the hips and shoulders. The bed’s 5 inches of foam and 4 inches of coils provide support and comfort for every sleep position. Plus, the 120-night trial period gives you ample time to test out the mattress.
If you’re planning on sharing this mattress with a partner or pet, it didn’t score as high in motion transfer, meaning you may be disturbed by your co-sleeper’s tossing and turning. If this is a concern, check out the Brooklyn Aurora, which uses thick layers of memory foam to absorb movement.
- Mattress Type: Hybrid (foam and coils)
- Mattress Advisor Score: 9.1/10
- Customer Rating: 4.7/5
- Firmness: Soft (4/10), medium (6/10), or firm (8/10)
- Trial Period: 120 nights
Mattress Advisor’s Review Process
Each mattress on this list was put to the test (literally) in Mattress Advisor’s lab, which is located in Raleigh, North Carolina. Bedding experts spent over 1,200 hours evaluating and comparing mattresses using a 14-point testing methodology to find the best beds for your money.
While some of the factors tested are tied directly to performance, like responsiveness, edge support, and pressure relief, others are based around brand operations, such as customer service, shipping policies, and trial period. The Mattress Advisor team combines this proprietary methodology with in-depth interviews and customer experience to arrive at a weighted score out of 10.